Critics point to flaws in longevity research Scientists led by Thomas Perls and from Boston College noted July one in an on-line publication in Science that they had recognized one hundred fifty genetic markers that distinguish centenarians from people with average lifestyle spans with 77 % precision. Almost immediately the research came below fire simply because of a specialized flaw. Most of the controversy stems from the devices utilized to consider the genetic fingerprints of a little number of people in the study. Known as DNA or SNP chips, these gadgets probe thousands of genetic markers called single billiga polo ralph lauren nucleotide polymorphisms, or SNPs. These markers are locations in the genome exactly where most people have 1 letter of the fourletter DNA alphabet this kind of as an A and a smaller proportion of individuals have a different letter a G, C or T. All of the chips utilized in the research had been manufactured by Illumina, a San Diegobased biotech company. But 1 of the a number of lines of chip the research used, called the Illumina 610 array, has flaws that could prevent researchers from correctly figuring out some SNPs. That billiga uggs rea may introduce bias into the study and toss off the results. Ironically, the team's statistical analysis of the information generally a trouble place for SNP studies was very careful, states Nicholas Schork, a statistical geneticist at the Scripps Translational Science Institute and the Scripps Research Institute, both in La Jolla, Calif. "There are many things in the paper that they did to shield on their own against error, but this is 1 that slipped through the cracks and may not even have been on their radar," he says. While other scientists gave the BU scientists a lot of feedback on their analysis of the information when the group offered the results at scientific meetings, "they most likely had been never challenged by somebody saying, 'artifacts on the Illumina 610. Beware.'" "The jury is nonetheless out on the degree to which this issue might affect their outcomes," Schork says. "If it turns out that the whole factor was an artifact, that would be shocking." Some critics also question whether the research discovered as well numerous genetic markers related with exceptional longevity. "We went into this study anticipating there would be few longevity genes," states Nir Barzilai, who conducts research similar to the BU group's as director of the Institute for Getting older Research at Albert Einstein College of Medication in New York Metropolis. But the definition of "couple of" ranges from kopior uggs 1 researcher's estimate of 4 to another's of two,000, he states. His personal preliminary data, generated using a different population of individuals and various SNP chips, also indicate that about 150 ralph lauren online SNPs separate the exceptionally longlived from people who reside an average lifestyle span. Barzilai and the BU group also concur on another important point. People who reside to 100 and beyond have just as numerous genetic variants
留言列表
